I am noticing a bit of confusion in fitness lately – confusion between sports and military training and exercise for health and well-being. I want you to be a savvy fitness consumer who gets what you want from your investment. Let’s take a look at the difference between the two approaches and see what you think:
If you were an athlete or military professional at some point in your life, the switch may be challenging. Those approaches to exercise can be strongly ingrained in your approach to movement. If you have done a fitness program with a sports-minded approach in the past, or admire those who do, this approach can be so enmeshed in your thinking about exercise, they can seem to be one and the same. But clearly, they are not.
Here are questions to ask yourself to be sure you are training for health and well-being:
- Am I pushing through pain and discomfort in my fitness class/program?
- Who is my primary guide for what is right for my body – a “fitness expert” or how my body feels with a certain exercise?
- How often do I ignore and “tough out” pain with exercise?
- How often do I get injured when I am on a fitness program?
- Am I consistent with exercise all year long?
- Does my exercise program leave me too sore and exhausted to move more throughout my day?
- Am I feeling and living better as a result of my training?
Are your answers more in line with the training approach on the right or the left of the chart above?
If you are ignoring pain, listening to a trainer more than your body, feeling sore and exhausted more often than energized, inconsistent with exercise, have a love/hate relationship with exercise, and/or have sustained an injury as a result of your training – you may be using a sports approach to health and well-being training.
If you feel better mentally and physically, have less pain and injury, are listening to your body, are consistent all year long, have more energy and stamina and strength to enjoy life – congratulations! You have found a fitness program for well-being.
This is not to say sports, athletic, or military training is wrong – it is simply a different goal than training for health and well-being. Sure, there is some crossover between the two ways of training the body.
The big difference is that sports/military training has a higher risk of injury and is not designed for sustainability long term. If you want your weight loss to be sustainable – you need a fitness plan that is sustainable as well.
Look back at the blog series on fitness I did a few weeks ago for more informative about fitness designed for health and well-being.
Keep Moving, Be Well,
Please share these posts with anyone you know interested in losing weight with or without weight loss surgery. Click here to learn more about the UMass Memorial Weight Center
These weekly blogs are general guidelines. These guidelines apply to patients who are cleared by a physician for the type of exercise described. Please contact your physician with any concerns or questions. Always report any symptoms associated with exercise, such as pain, irregular heartbeats, and dizziness or fainting, to your physician.
7 responses to “What are you training for?”
Ive never thought about the difference but I love this chart. I see myself having both sides as my typical routine. Great post!
Great post! I find myself often questioning if I’m working hard we bought. The post helps put things in perspective. I have found a video series I love and the trainer has the same philosophy as you regarding listening to your body and doing what you can. She’s very encouraging. For those trying to strike that balance, check out Jessica Smith TV videos.
Pingback: You Get What You Train For | Keep Moving Weekly
Pingback: How Much is Enough? | Keep Moving Weekly
Pingback: Attitude for Sustainability | Keep Moving Weekly
Pingback: Myths that Build Barriers. Part One: No Pain No Gain | Keep Moving Weekly
Pingback: Read between the lines | Keep Moving Weekly